|Episode(s)||The Long Con|
|Played By||Finn Armstrong|
Arthur was a man who was conned into buying phony jewelry by Sawyer. While with his friend Peter, Arthur was confronted by Sawyer who asked him if he was interested in buying jewelry which he was selling for $100 a peice. When Sawyer's partner in crime Cassidy approached and purchases two of the necklaces that were claimed to be worth well over a $1000, Arthur and Peter stop Sawyer who is about to leave, and purchase some of his jewelry.